4. Natasha Lyonne (Jessica)
Natasha played Jessica’s role in American Pie. She was the foul-mouthed high girl who was wiser than her age.
5. Eddie Kaye Thomas (Paul Finch)
Another high school lad in American Pie cast was Eddie Kaye Thomas who got his big break starring as Paul Finch.
6. Chris Owen (Chuck Sherman)
Chris Owen played as Chuck Sherman, or “The Sherminator.” Chuck was a dorky guy who believed himself to be the ladies’ man.